Hyakunen Renbo by Mashiba Nao (2009)
My Category: Short Light Romance
Completed: 2 volumes, 9 chapters. Scanalated by Mousou Scans, but they seem to be on hiatus now. They've completed this series.
(Source: Mousou Scans)
My thoughts: Not my cup of tea, I guess some will like it. For me, acceptable art, pretty superficial, wouldn't read again. Doesn't make me believe in the characters nor the love. Almost acceptable to pass time with, I guess~?
Story: 2/10
The premise was rather interesting, since it was about a long lived witch and a young prince. It would have been nice to see more development in their relationship over time but I guess the length of the manga was too short for much of that... I didn't buy into the whole royal drama because it is rather overdone and in this case simple and formulatic. A plus point is that it wasn't confusing and it made sense (mostly). If you ignore everything else there is a certain cuteness in their love I suppose. Not much to comment on since it's short~
Characters: 3/10
There was basically only the two main characters and the royal brother in this short manga. I felt like the brother had potential to be a more dynamic and interesting character but the author seemed to choose to let him go on the 'bad guy' route... sad. I found both Eva and Louis to be rather flat and cookie-cut character types, I'm sorry to say. Eva seems cold on the outside but is warm and caring on the inside, while Louis is kind-hearted, strong, and acts cute and flirty to Eva alone.
Art: 5/10
The art reminds me of Tanemura Arina-sensei's art in certain ways... I'm not a fan of her artwork, so I can't really comment upon it. Overall it did manage to convey the messages clearly, but there's a lot of room for improvement.
Enjoyment: 3/10
I did not particularly enjoy this manga, but it wasn't painful to read either; although I did cringe at some parts. As I've said though, it's not too bad and it's probably just not my taste.
Overall, 3.5/10.
No comments:
Post a Comment